Thursday, January 3, 2008

New Year resolutions

by Bee

I have . . .

TWO.

My resolutions for 2008 are to foster

1.Kindness (a warm heart) and

2.Tolerance (an open mind)

in my interactions.

I sense . . .

that practising these precepts is not as straightforward as they appear.

I'm not even completely sure what they entail.

I read . . .

various definitions of kindness. They include words like 'nice', 'polite', 'generous', 'compassionate'. To me, it means empathy and the desire to make someone's life, including your own, a tad easier.

Like the conductor in a crowded bus who asks you how you are, and gives you a smile as he hands you your ticket. Partly, he's doing it to make your journey less tedious. Partly, he's doing it for himself, to reaffirm his ability to make a positive difference.

The true expression of non-violence is compassion. Some people seem to think that compassion is just a passive emotional response instead of rational stimulus to action. To experience genuine compassion is to develop a feeling of closeness to others combined with a sense of responsibility for their welfare. True compassion develops when we ourselves want happiness and not suffering for others, and recognize that they have every right to pursue this. - the Dalai Lama


I have resolved to be kind to others, as well as to myself. In fact, I need to practise kindness towards myself first.

Hence, I have resolved to do something nice for myself every day, no matter how big or small. It is important to step back, reflect for a moment, and resist the temptation to be too harsh or judgemental on oneself. I also will forgive myself for letting others make me feel that I am not good enough.

I will also try to do atleast one kind deed towards others every day. That means telling them how much they mean to me, or by simply refraining from losing my temper when I am tempted to.

Easier said and done, but what have I got to lose by trying?

Here's Aristotle's understanding of tolerance.

“It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it.”

Entertaining an opposing point of view as a possibility is much more difficult than it appears.

I ask . . .

How are kindness and tolerance different from doormatdom?

I have no romantic illusions of getting along famously with the rest of the world and of being able to interact with others in a manner that is unconditionally compassionate and non-judgemental.

Let's face it. There's a lot of toxic, selfish behaviour around me. I display it too, from time to time.

Dealing with it takes up a lot of my energy. Trying to ignore it while being the brunt of it only fosters stress and resentment. My solution is to detach by saying, "That person behaves this way because that's the best way he/she knows to respond to these cirumstances."

I'm not condoning that behaviour, I'm not making excuses for it. I'm just choosing to stay away from it. If the person who exhibits that behaviour wants to know why I am distancing myself from him/her, I tell him/her that 'x' action bothers me.

They can choose to make amends if they want to. If they don't, I will keep my distance, because it is my duty to be kind to myself.

Similarly, if I exhibit behaviour that I realise is offensive to someone else, I will apologise and change my behaviour. Whether to accept the apology or not is up to them. If they do not accept my apology, it is their prerogative as the injured party, and I have to respect that as well.

Kindness to me is all about respect and boundaries. I enforce and maintain my boundaries, and try to respect those of others. It is a lot of work, but I'm hoping it will get easier with time and practice.

There will be people who will call you 'mean' if you choose not to interact with them. However, as long as I am not harming them, slandering them, or exploiting them, I am being kind to myself and to them by keeping my distance.

Being kind to myself includes not letting myself be guilted when I am called 'mean'.

If I do not place my hand over a hot stove, I am not being mean to the stove. I am merely acknowledging that a hot stove is not good for my hand.

The energy I would have spent interacting with folks who stress me out can be better chanelled in the company of others who energise me.

For someone as opinionated and vocal as myself, being 'tolerant', personally, is a much bigger challenge than being kind.

I respect everyone's right to voice their opinions. So, if someone wants to worship toenails, or drink camel piss at teatime, I respect their right to do that. Now, respecting someone's right to do or say something is not the same as respecting the belief or deed itself.

I think . . .

worshipping toenails is weird. Not wrong, but weird.

And I think hunting for sport is plain wrong.

The problem of tolerance lies in how to combine loyalty to one's own value system with the value systems of others. Worshipping toenails just strikes me as quirky. Discriminating against gays in the workplace does clash with my value system.

My aim is to uphold my belief system in my own life and try to minimise my interactions with establishments and people whose practices clash with my values.
I respect their right to express themselves, but I am not compelled to give their beliefs the same weight as I give my own.

Is it judgmental for me to avoid buying the products of a company with sexist hiring policies? Probably. But as Will Rogers pointed out, "Broad-minded is just another way of saying a fellow's too lazy to form an opinion."

I don't expect to change the mind of the person who doesn't want gays in the army. Denying someone the right to express himself/herself is intolerance. Refusing to accept or embrace that viewpoint is not intolerance.

If that person joins my biking club, I'm not going to make him feel unwelcome. However, if he talks about keeping gays out of the club, I will definitely voice my opinion.

Hence, to me, being tolerant implies not allowing myself to be gaslighted or made to believe that I am bigoted because I think putting toenails in a silver vial and lighting a candle in front of it is silly. If my friend wants a ride to a place to worship toenails, I may drive her there, but if she asks me to join in the worship, I will decline.

If she wants to go hunting for sport, and asks me to join, I will tell her, "I won't, because I think it is wrong." I may even deny her a ride, because killing an animal for sport clashes with my value system.

By the same token, I have to accept that in a free, pluralistic society, if I state that the life of a deer is as valuable as the life of a man, someone may think I am silly, and say so.

Novelist Tom Robbins hit the nail on the head when he said, “Stay committed to your decisions, but stay flexible in your approach.”



Dear reader, I wish you a New Year that is productive and peaceful. How do you define kindness and tolerance? I'd love to know.

- Bee

18 comments:

Priya said...

Bee, this a very well written post. Being tolerant has been on my list too, I am so judgmental and sarcastic with people I dislike. I know it hurts them and still can't resist it sometimes.
Aristotle's saying really makes the point, its truly a challenge to be able to entertain an opposing idea.
Another one of my resolutions is to call people who care about me more often this year. I am very very bad when it comes to staying in touch...pathetic infact :((

chef@HC said...

Charity begins at home. Likewise, everything we want to be with others starts from your self. And my idea of kindness is to respect your genuine feelings and do not resent them for feeling a certain way. If u dont like somebody's action, it is rather genuine to say it or stay away from rather than being fakely kind for the sake of it.. Now, thats unkind to myself and it sort of spoils my condition...
lala

sra said...

Bee, best of luck with your resolutions. I think I share the same views on the definitions of tolerance and kindness.

Asha said...

Kinder and gentler Bee in 2008!!! I likey!!!
I have always been those since childhood, I emulate my dad.
I remember making friends with lonely girls who sat alone in school and college, when everybody else laughed at them bcos they are poor or dark skinned or "low caste" etc and I never cared when my peers made fun of me for being friends with them!! I am still like that, don't care what people think, I see the big picture!:P

Happy cook said...

I guess i am kinder to ppl.
Till i read our post i hadn't thought about having a newyears resolution.
I think I have to be much more tolerante to the views of my daughters opinion.
I agree it is much more difficult to be tolerante than to be kind.

Happy cook said...

Oh forgot to say HAPPY NEWYEAR to both of you :-))))

Revathi said...

Wow, wow, wow. Completely wow. PERFECT!

Rajitha said...

agree with every word you have said..could not have put it better...

Anali said...

This is a really good post, but I must admit to laughing about the toenail worship thing. I guess kindness is treating someone with caring and respect and some extra sweetness too because you want them to feel good and happy.

Tolerance... That word has annoyed me a bit since it started being used in the context of diversity. There is a certain amount of hostility that I feel in that word sometimes. Like someone merely tolerates me, because they have to. I don't really like the word. It reminds me of the word "cordial." It's kind of a cold term. Sort of like I don't want to say that I don't like someone very much, but that we're cordial with each other. Not a very nice feeling.

Cynthia said...

I'd have to say that I define them just as you do but like you suggested, I have to internalise some of those things - especially to be kinder to myself.

A very happy new year to you dearest.

bee said...

thanks for all your input, and anali, i agree. 'tolerance' can be used in a passive/aggressive manner. thanks for highlighting that.

Miri said...

Thanks for sharing your resolutions and hoping that you have much success in your way to fulfilling them!

Tolerance to me is to stop being judgemental and put yourself in another's shoes - yes I may not like something, may disagree - but what would I do if I were in those exact same circumstances
And even if I still cant stomach the behaviour/ action - then walk away - isnt that always a choice?

Pragyan said...

A very well-written post, indeed!

enjay said...

Kindness and Tolerance. We prize ourselves for living in an increasingly 'tolerant' society, but I believe kindness is the most under-rated of all human qualities. Every day, I see people being unkind. It is so easy, and if you add a dash of humor, people might actually begin to admire you for it! Being unkind is not 'being frank', 'calling a spade a spade', or even, 'not taking shit from anyone.'Being unkind is just that, bring unkind.

Kindness, to me, is about respect, and actually encompasses tolerance. Very simply, doing unto others as you would want done unto you. So I respect people's privacy, I try not to judge personal choices, and I try not to push back when pushed.How to be kind to myself? I try not to take myself too seriously.

Lovely post.

Santhi said...

Ah..some worthy resolutions dear bee, but knowledge, awareness and practice are three different things..I agree when you say that by being tolerant you give others the freedom to believe and do what they choose to, but where do you draw the line...If we all did this, then there would be utter chaos..I mean, I may be taking an extreme view, but if we are all tolerant and someone believes that killing is a sport, then should we be tolerant or should we stop it ? I dont even know whether I am making sense...but you have infact triggered a lot of thoughts ( some not so tolerant and kind :-) )....

Mamatha said...

A very well-written post Bee.

ThreeTastes said...

To everything you say in this post, I say, "Amen."
To me, kindness and tolerance both have to be rooted in the heart. If you start with a love for all persons around you, how can you not act with kindness towards them, and try to understand their actions and beliefs?

I often see a disconnect in seemingly kind actions and tolerant practices, when the person performing them is not sincere. You see it in his eyes, her hard smile. In fact, I've grown to loathe the word "tolerance" because so many people use it to mean they will put up with you just enough not to get themselves in trouble.

I wish all the best in your quest to foster kindness and tolerance in this year! Let me know if I can help. ; )

Roshni Mitra Chintalapati said...

Yeah, I'm getting to a point where I think associating with people whom I just don't see eye-to-eye with as a waste of my time. My husband has a let's-get-along-with-everyone attitude but nowadays I just cannot stomach stupid/toxic behaviour! Live and let live but get-outta-my-face!!